February’s library commission meeting saw continued strain in the relationship between the Warren County Library Commission and the public. The meeting received an impressive turnout from the public, and after a brief report from the Library director, which shared updates on the first shipment from Midwest Library Services, the new book vendor for the Warren County Library System.
The first shipment went smoothly, and the New Jersey library association conference was a success as well. Some major leaks were discovered at the Richard D. Gardner Branch, but the Catherine Dickson Hofman Branch’s leaks weathered the storms without issue.
Programs across the branches have been well attended despite the winter weather conditions, and staff is preparing for New Jersey Markers day on Saturday, March 21, which is one of the most popular events of the year, averaging approximately 750 attendees in past years. The Gardner, Hofman, Northeast, and Southwest branches will offer different stem-based activities for all ages from 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.; the full list of activities is available on the library website.
Discussion on the Revised Library Bylaws
After the director’s report, Chairperson Pasquarelli brought up the timeline of when the finalized pdf of the revised bylaws will be posted to the website. Copies of the amended bylaws will be distributed among commission members, who will notify attorney Joe Bell of any final suggestions.
The bylaws are to be voted into effect at the March 24 meeting, and the agenda, including a PDF of the finalized bylaws, will be posted to the library’s website on March 19, the Thursday before the meeting. Written comments can be emailed to the commission until the day before the meeting on Monday, March 23. Written comments missing the deadline will be considered at the following meeting on April 28.
Public Comments
Public comments yielded the same concerns as previous meetings about accountability and transparency, particularly regarding the upcoming revisions to the bylaws. A member of the public alleged that November’s Warren County Library executive session was accidentally livestreamed to the public via Zoom, and expressed concern about the alleged contents of the session.
Chairperson Pasquerelli was alleged to encourage board members to correspond directly with her regarding any concerns about the minutes of previous meetings to avoid public scrutiny. Minutes of the executive session will be drafted as a result of these concerns.
Comments from Attorney Joe Bell
Addressing why draft bylaws were not distributed to the public sooner, Attorney Joe Bell stated that draft documents are never required to be distributed to the public prior to their adoption: “The rational behind that is things would never really get done if you couldn’t finalize a document without the public being able to comment, and critique, and make changes.”
He elaborated that the open public records act excludes “advisory consultative and deliberative material” from the definition of government record. He explained that a draft needs to be in final form before it is shared with the public for functionality purposes. “The commission is technically doing more than its required to do by putting it out ahead of time before it’s presented at a meeting,” he asserted.
A full discussion of the contents of the bylaws will be held at the March 24 meeting, where the public will be allowed to comment on agenda items before the bylaws are voted into effect. Interested parties may find details about the meeting as well as registration for the virtual attendance option on the Warren County Library website.
Julien Smith is a student journalist from Northwest New Jersey. He has had a lifelong fascination with all things journalism, and mentors elementary and middle school aged kids with the program “Indy Kids” in NYC. He lives in between Hope and Blairstown, and usually can be found puttering around his garden or with his nose in a textbook.






