History came full circle on Sept. 18 when Rutherfurd Hall unveiled an exhibit featuring rare portraits by Elizabeth Shoumatoff, the acclaimed Russian-born artist who painted Franklin D. Roosevelt.
At the heart of the show is Shoumatoff’s finished 1943 portrait of President Franklin D. Roosevelt — previously held in a private collection and now visible to the public, on loan from his confidante Lucy Mercer Rutherfurd’s family. The exhibit brings together art, politics and personal history, highlighting ties between Roosevelt and the Rutherfurds of Warren County.

Shoumatoff, who never held a single gallery showing, painted over 2,000 portraits of twentieth century luminaries, including members of prominent families such as the Firestones and the du Ponts. She even painted the official White House portrait of President Lyndon Johnson and Lady Bird Johnson. Every piece was rare, but one unassuming 8-by-10-inch piece attracted the place of greatest honor: the completed 1943 portrait of President Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Roosevelt’s ties to Warren County, and to Rutherfurd Hall, were personal. On the heels of the 80th anniversary of his death, it’s fitting that his portrait returned to a place that held deep meaning for him.
Rutherfurd Hall was home to Lucy Mercer Rutherford, a woman with whom Roosevelt would develop a “tremendous affection,” historian Joan Leckie Salvas said. “It was called the greatest affection of the American presidency.”
The Rutherfurd Connection
In 1914, Eleanor Roosevelt hired 23-year-old Lucy Mercer as her social secretary. Two years later, Mercer and Franklin Roosevelt began a deeply personal relationship that would significantly shape the course of their lives.
Eleanor discovered the nature of the relationship in 1918, leading to its temporary end. In 1920, Mercer married wealthy widower Winthrop Rutherfurd.

The Rutherfurds have deep roots in Warren County. Their presence dates to 1756, when Walter Rutherford emigrated from Scotland to fight in the French and Indian War. He married Catherine Alexander Parker in 1758, and together they purchased extensive lands in Warren County.
His grandsons, Rutherfurd Stuyvesant and Winthrop Rutherfurd, expanded the family’s holdings dramatically. By the early 20th century, the brothers owned 6,800 acres out of Allamuchy Township’s total 13,000 acres. Between 1903 and 1905, Winthrop built Rutherfurd Hall as a summer residence, the better to raise his beloved smooth fox terriers — including Warren Remedy, the only dog in Westminster Kennel Club history to win Best in Show three times.
Lucy Rutherfurd’s path intersected with Shoumatoff’s at the Wilcox Hotel in 1937. Lucy requested a portrait of her mother, which Shoumatoff happily completed. This began a partnership that would produce at least seven Rutherfurd family portraits.
Meanwhile, though Franklin Roosevelt and Lucy Mercer Rutherfurd remained with their respective partners, they stayed in touch. When Roosevelt’s health began to fail in the early 1940s, they began meeting again.
In 1943, Rutherfurd asked her now good friend Shoumatoff to paint the president, if it could be arranged.
It would be a tremendous honor, Shoumatoff replied.
She completed the portrait at the White House soon after.
The Story of a Portrait
After Lucy’s husband, Winthrop, died in 1944, she spent more time with the ailing Roosevelt. Earlier this year, Salvas delivered a lecture called “The Long Goodbye” about that final year of Roosevelt’s life, when Lucy was especially important to him.

In April 1945, Lucy arranged another portrait session for Roosevelt in Warm Springs, Georgia. As Shoumatoff worked in watercolor, Roosevelt complained of a terrible pain in the back of his head. Moments later, he slumped forward, unconscious. He died of a stroke later that day.
Shoumatoff’s unfinished portrait of Roosevelt became her most famous piece. It remains in Roosevelt’s Georgia retreat.
After his death, Eleanor Roosevelt discovered Shoumatoff’s finished 1943 portrait in one of Franklin’s desk drawers. She had never seen it before. Spotting the artist’s name in the corner, she realized who must have arranged it and asked Franklin’s cousin Margaret “Daisy” Suckley: “Please send this to Mrs. Rutherfurd.”
Lucy responded to the package with a compassionate thank-you note. She died three years later, and the 1943 finished portrait remained in her South Carolina home for the next 80 years.
Her granddaughter, Lucy Knowles, helped bring the portrait to light decades later. After hearing Salvas’ lecture in April, Knowles contacted her to say she had the 1943 portrait — and would loan it to Rutherfurd Hall for display.
That sparked a ripple among Rutherfurd descendants. Guy Rutherfurd called siblings and cousins to see who else might have inherited Shoumatoff paintings. Several agreed to loan theirs for the sake of a historical exhibit.
On Thursday, family members recalled the process with good humor. It had been quite a process to discover who had inherited which painting, leading to teasing accusations of being “grabby.”
The final exhibit, “The Patience to Pose: Elizabeth Shoumatoff, the Rutherfurds, and President Franklin D. Roosevelt,” features Roosevelt’s 1943 portrait , seven other Shoumatoff paintings of Rutherfurd family members, and ancestral portraits collected from the estate, dating as far back as 1784. Together, they tell the story of the Rutherfurds’ role in early American history.
Legacy, History, and a Bittersweet Cinderella Story
The exhibit opened with a lecture by Salvas, who brought the enthusiasm and dynamism from her long career as a high school teacher. She described the adventures of curating the show — some academic, like combing through books by Roosevelt Press Secretary Jonathan Daniels, and some physical, like a research trip to Roosevelt’s Hyde Park residence.

“I have a problem,” she said, “with Americans not knowing American history.”
The story of the Rutherfurds and Roosevelts is an unusual chapter in that history — one that, Salvas said, deserves to be told.
“This is such an extraordinarily gracious story,” she said. “It is this remarkable story of two women Jonathan Daniels called the two Cinderellas — Eleanor Roosevelt and Lucy Mercer Rutherford — who had the misfortune to love the same man.”
Daniels echoed that sentiment in a letter to Lucy Mercer Rutherfurd’s daughter after her death: “This is a story of two Cinderellas and one prince.”
The Rutherfurd Hall Foundation plans to continue hosting events inviting the public to explore local history. Next year, Salvas said, she hopes to highlight Walter Rutherfurd’s adventures during the American Revolution — fitting for the nation’s 250th birthday.
For more information, visit rutherfurdhall.org.
Chip O'Chang is an educator, fiction writer, and lifelong resident of New Jersey. He has also written for My Life Publications and NJ Indy. He lives in the NJ Skylands with his partner, two cats, and and a bearded dragon.






