Although not every county in New Jersey has identical voting machines, the counties do all fall under a single state law for certification of votes.
Warren County clerk Holly Mackey said certain procedures do depend on individual machines, but all counties fall under Title 19 of the state code.
The voting machines in Warren County provide a paper confirmation of the vote, so each voter can see if there is a mistake or incorrect vote.
Mackey and her staff demonstrate the voting machines at the Warren County Farmers Fair each summer to show voters how the machines work and instill confidence in their safety.
Votes are counted electronically. The Board of Elections may conduct a manual count of voter-verifiable paper ballots and will tally all overvotes, undervotes, blank ballots, spoiled ballots and cancellations recorded on the paper record.
When the votes come off the machines, they represent an unofficial tally. That tally is reported in each county to representatives of the media outlets in that county, including an Associated Press (AP) “stringer” who calls the results in to the New York headquarters of AP. Each media outlet in the country that subscribes to AP gets those unofficial results and announces them.
Those unofficial votes are canvassed and certified. This entails collecting and reconciling all ballot materials. The canvass starts officially when the polls close, although some early and mail-in votes may have been canvassed earlier.
Each county does a local canvass which is a thorough proofreading and review of all of the pertinent documents in each precinct. Each state compiles all local canvasses.
The timeline of this varies by how complicated it is. In a primary election with a low turnout it is completed more rapidly than in a general election, especially a presidential election. It also depends on whether the state counts mail-in ballots before Election Day. It may also depend on how quickly military absentee ballots are processed.
After the count, certain districts, chosen at random by the attorney general’s office, are audited under a stringent set of rules. Those districts are not certified while the audit is going on.
Independent Election Audits
Under Title 19:61-9, the state attorney general must appoint an independent, professional audit team in each county to oversee the county election officials who are required to conduct random counts of paper records.
Audits shall be conducted in at least 2% of the districts involved in the election, the law states. Election districts are selected for auditing on the years of Congressional or Senate elections, but may be audited for any other election held in those districts during alternate years.
The audit is designed to ensure there is at least a 90% chance that if all of the votes were counted by hand the result would be exactly the same.
The state has rules for who should be on the audit committee such as members cannot be a candidate for office or part of any political campaign committee or an employee of the attorney general or a voting machine company.
Audit reports are subject to the same chain of custody as ballots are when they are brought to the county courthouse from each polling district.
Election auditors must compare the vote tallies in the final cumulative report that they create to the official results announced by the county.
Recounts may be requested in any district as long as the request is filed within 17 days of the election, including elections that were the subject of an audit. In New Jersey, no matter how close an election is, recounts are not automatic, according to the Ballotpedia website.
Possibly the most famous recount in New Jersey history was the 1981 gubernatorial election recount. Congressman James J. Florio requested a recount of the vote when he lost to New Jersey Assembly Speaker Thomas H. Kean by just more than 1,700 votes. The final tally gave Kean the win by 1,797 votes, the closest margin in the state’s history.
Without a lengthy recount, the county clerk of each county is required to make available within 90 days on the county website a table or database containing all results from each district including mail-in ballots.
New Jersey voters can follow their own ballots through the New Jersey Voter Information Portal which includes a “Track My Ballot” tool.
Jane Primerano is a veteran journalist covering Warren County municipalities, agriculture, and historic preservation. Her work has appeared in New Jersey Monthly, New Jersey Farmer, and more. A past president of NJ Press Women and SPJ NJPro, she lives in Hope Village and enjoys music, singing with the Warren County Community Singers, reading, and the Jersey Shore.






